You’re Fucking Your Brother?

erotic literature, sexy stories, female erotica, erotic short stories, free erotica, adult fiction, caffieri.com, XXX stories, erotic fiction, short sex stories, erotic super shorts, adult stories, sexually explicit stories, porn stories, short erotic stories, kinky sex stories,  erotic stories on YouTube, humor, xxx short stories, sexy humor, incest, brother sister sex, threesome,

By Lauren McAllister

Jennifer and I had been a secret item for quite a while. It all began one glorious summer night when I was invited to a sleepover at her house. We goofed around, ate pizza and laughed our asses off but as soon as the lights went out, her hand went down my baby dolls like a fox after a rabbit. I was a tad shocked at first but the longer her wonderfully rhythmic fingers were down there, the more I liked it. We’ve been fucking and sucking on a regular basis ever since. It’s not that I don’t like boys – they can be really quite alluring – but Jenny’s unbelievably talented tongue has yet to get me pregnant. In fact, Jen and I often talk about the persons of the male persuasion in quite complimentary terms while we’re rubbing each other cross-eyed on a Friday night. Plus, I’ve had a good number of healthy wanks while staring at a picture of the Jonas Brothers.

I’d also had the odd unclean thought about Jennifer’s twin brother, Joey. He was as cute as a button. Well, he’d have to be because he’s the boy version of Jenny, except with bigger muscles and a dick (I theorized). I always thought he was a very sweet guy but obviously, I couldn’t really make any sort of a play for him because he’s my lover’s brother. That would have been far too creepy and awkward… Even for me. I did often wonder though, if he had any inkling of the unspeakable acts I was perpetrating on his sister in the very next room. Charlie Rich was certainly right about “closed doors!”

It was after one of those unspeakable act afternoons that Jennifer dropped the big bomb. We had just had mind-blowing sex. 69s are so hard to get right and managing to adequately satisfy both parties is always a challenged but this one rocked! We kind of hit a synchronized lick rhythm and came within seconds of each other. I was on the bottom, my favorite position for a 69. I liked to be almost literally smothered in pussy. Jenny’s face-humping first buried my nose in her love hole and then she squirted about a gallon of girl cum onto my forehead and the pillow. Yowsa! Pretty damn special.

So, we’re laying their in each other’s naked arms, basking in the glow of quims well eaten and she treats me to a big, wet kiss.

“I’m a little worried about my brother,” she sighs.

“Is he okay? He’s not sick, is he?” As I say, I really liked the guy.

“He’s thinking of getting a girlfriend.”

“Well, he should have no trouble with that. He’s as cute as a button.”

“That’s what I’m afraid of. I don’t want some bitch stealing him away from me.”

“Well, this theoretical “she” wouldn’t be stealing him away from you. You’d still be his sister.”

“I’m going to tell you something, Carissa, and I don’t want you freaking out.”

“Of course not, baby. You can tell me anything.”

“I am so glad to hear you say that because I am fucking my brother.”

“You’re what!!???”

“You said you wouldn’t freak out.”

“I didn’t know you were going to tell me you’re committing incest!”

“Don’t be so dramatic. Incest is having sex with your father.” Jenny shuddered. “Banging your brother happens all the time. It’s just normal, healthy youthful curiosity. And you said yourself, he’s as cute as a button.”

Then a bell went off in my head. “Has this been going on long?

“A few years.”

“A few years? Like the same years you’ve been fucking me?”

“It started out as just looking at each other’s parts. Then we started masturbating together. It was nice to have the company. Pretty soon we were masturbating each other and then one thing led to the inevitable other and… I wanted to tell you.”

“Well, aren’t you a living doll?”

“Are you interested in what I need to ask you are you just going to turn all judgemental Southern Baptist on me?”

“I’m sorry. I’m just in a bit of shock….” Another thought. “Say, you didn’t ever have me eat you our right after… “
”Of course not. Just because I’m banging my brother, doesn’t mean I’m a disgusting pig.”

“Well… ?”

“Well, I’d like you to be Joey’s girlfriend.”

This again, was not what I was expecting. “But you’re fucking me,” I declared the obvious.

“And I desperately want that to continue, unabated.”

“So you’d be fucking me and Joey would be fucking me and you’d be fucking Joey?”

“See. This could work out so perfectly for everyone. And, I am so glad you asked that question because my parent are leaving for the weekend and I thought the three of us… “

“So you’re proposing a weekend threesome with me and the Dobson twins.”

“I’ll bake your favorite brownies.”

“While you’re brother is eating my muffin?”

I won’t bore you with the details of the rest of our tortured conversation. Let’s just say that in the end, and I have no idea how – I swear that girl could talk a Quaker into giving up eating oatmeal  – but she inexplicably convinced me to come over so she could watch me get boned by her brother. And then the three of us would somehow get together and top off the evening by committing unholy acts of unpardonable depravity . I was definitely unhappy by my impending eternal damnation but also strangely turned on. I mean, it was just so wash-your-snatch-in-Lysol yucky, that I couldn’t stop thinking about it.

When I arrived at the the Dobson estate, armed with an armful Blue Nun bottles, things seemed normal. Way too normal. When a fellow of the male persuasion believes he’s going to spend the end of the evening romping around in your pleasure tube, he always has a certain look in his eye. Joey did not have that look. He had the look of a guy who was going to have a barbecue with his sister and her best friend. What gives?

“So, is Joey cool with what’s supposed to be going down tonight?  Pardon the pun.” I queried my nervous looking girlfriend.

“I haven’t actually told him.”

“You haven’t told him???”

“Hey, you’re a good looking girl. I’m a good looking girl. I figured things would just happen naturally.”

“Like they’ve been naturally happening for the last few years?”

“Will you relax. I’ve got the hot tub on. The trick is to pour the exact amount of Blue Nun down his throat to make him horny but not impotent.”

“I assume we’re bare-backing him,” I sighed.
”Of course,” my she-devil of a lover rolled her eyes.

It wasn’t too hard to get Joey interested in the hot tub but I could tell he felt more than a little weirded out when it came time to whip out his cock in front of me. Perhaps it was the way I was staring at his equipment. But it was well worth staring at. He was cut, had a nicely shaped helmet, it was shaved (that had to be Jennifer’s doing) and I really liked the way it hung down below his balls like the head of a really sad horse. But all that anxiety seemed to be forgotten the second my tits and ass hit the night air. Go figure!

So, in we plopped, warmed by the the swirling bubbly waters and the wondrous mellowizing properties of Germanic vino.

I had strict instructions to sit up straight, so my nipples would be visible above the waterline. Jenny adopted a similar posture.

So there we were, waving our tits around like a couple of sluts, and trying to figure out what the next step would be. I received a tap in the twat from Jennifer to get the poon party started.

“Say Joey,” I blurted out, with no real idea of what I was going to say next. “I’ve always wondered what it would be like to suck Jenny’s cock. Well, you look just like her, how about it?”

“Pardon?”

“Well, I’ve been fucking your sister for quite a while now, and I’d just really appreciate it if you’d let me slobber on that delightful knob of yours.”

The was a pregnant pause. Both Jennifer and Joey looked dumbstruck. And, I guess I was the dumbie that struck them.”

“What a sense of humor,” burst forth with a tortured laugh.

I’d had enough of this bullshit. I turned to face Joey nose-to-nose. “Listen, I know you’ve been boinking your sister and if you want me to keep this rather embarrassing fact quiet, I want you to sit on the side of this tub and show me your cock. How’s that for straight shooting?”

Joe timidly nodded and did as I said.

I pulled his legs apart, leaned my elbows on his thighs and swallowed that big, pink motherfucker. I liked it. It turns out, Joe had a boner the size of the Der Wienerschnitzel truck and I was duly impressed. It was also as hard as Ann Coulter’s heart. “Get over here and suck his balls, while I work on the head and shaft,” I instructed.

Jennifer hesitated.
”Come on, you silly bitch, it’s not like your exactly a stranger to this guy’s nutack.”

I was kind of getting a buzz out of ordering everyone around. It was a perfectly fair arrangement really, since I was the only non-relative in the tub.

And since my assuming of the dictatorial crown, events and body parts had really begun to heat up. Joey’s dick was sliding around on my tongue and Jenny’s fingers were sliding around in my vulva while she gently gnawed at bro’s scrotum. Rivulets of please were rippling up my abdomen and mixing beautifully with the bubbles swirling around my nipples. I had so many tingly sensations going on in my twat, I felt compelled to order everyone indoors in search of a drier and less restrictive venue. We were all over each other on the way into the bedroom and ended up commandeering their parent’s bed because it gave us more room to play.

Within seconds of alighting on the soon-to-be-stained mattress, Jenny was sucking on my tits and Joey had his face parked in my butter dish. Yes, Captain Carissa was really beginning to enjoy herself. It wasn’t long before Joe was on his back and I had my cream crevice resting on his chin. Jenny was riding Joey’s cock like she was running second in the Preakness. Watching her brother’s penis disappear inside my girl, as she lowered herself down on it, was a total head-trip and a major deposit in my spank bank. I leaned forward to play with her magnificent tits as we licked each others tonsils. I could tell that both of us were headed for majorly insane climaxes. I tried not to grind my mound too hard into Joey’s nose and lips but it just felt so fucking good. Now, the nether tightening started to take hold and I could not be held responsible for Jenny’s brother’s safety. For her part, she was riding him so hard, he was in danger of having his cock snapped of. The poor guy was trapped under two sex driven maniacs. I was the first to cum, by maybe a second. It rose up inside me like a Hawaiian volcano. Holy shit, it rocked every muscle and bone in my body. Meanwhile, Jennifer was screaming like she’d been stabbed. Blast after blast of cum-tastic contractions reduced me to a puddle of flesh on the bed, holding my ravaged solar plexus in one hand and my incandescent pussy in the other.

Jenny’s face looked like she was humping a penis made out of barbed wire but it was all pure psychotic determination to squeeze every last orgasmic molecule out of her brother’s rod. And then she went silent and flopped down on top of him. I could see her undulating pucker hole reacting to the dying embers of her apocalyptic cunt spasms

It took a few deep breaths to regain my senses, but once some conscious thought returned to my beleaguered brain, I quickly took Joey’s monster into my mouth. It was a tag team effort, me administering a few hard sucks and then handing it off to Sis for a few head bobs. We passed  his manhood back and forth for a couple of concentrated minutes and then I lifted up his legs so I could lick his asshole. Jenny then bore down on his dick to take him over the finish line. I’d never seen Jennifer suck cock before. She gave head to a guy as good as she gave to me! He started to moan and his sphincter began to tighten around my tongue. I heard a telltale grunt as Joey’s pant cannon fired off round after round of salty, gooey splooge onto the roof of his sister’s mouth. The second he stopped thrashing around, I jumped up from his third eye and Frenched my dearest Jenny. Her brother’s cum flowed freely between our two gaping maws as our tongues swirled around in a lake of rich, sticky jism. I felt a few drops drip down my chin and fall onto his pelvis. My, it was grand!

For the rest of the night, we fucked and sucked in every conceivable combination. My pussy was unbearably sore the next morning and I thought we were going to have to put Joey’s doowanger in a cast. Fortunately, with the aid of various soothing ointments and creams, we eventually made a full recovery. And… Jenny got her wish. I am now Joey’s official girlfriend… and his sister’s official girlfriend.

On the downside, I think I’m going to be needing those ointments and creams for some time to come.

The End

New and Exclusive Video for Caffieri.com and Patreon!

Catch All Are Videos on Our Patreon Site!

Please Subscribe and join our Patreon family.

When a horrible tragedy befalls all-world nice guy, Eddie, his best friend convinces his wife to help cheer him up. Life may suck, but luckily, so does Johnny’s bride.

Copyright Lauren McAllister 2022

%d bloggers like this: